Earlier this week, I was watching an episode of Grace & Frankie. It was “The Elevator” episode where Grace and Frankie are talking about motherhood. Grace accidentally let it slip that Frankie wouldn’t understand something about being a “real mother” because she was an adoptive mom and not a birth mom. By that logic, I’ll never be a real mom because I can’t have children. To them, I am not enough.
Boy, that really punched me right in the gut. I’m childless due to medical reasons, and it’s a sensitive subject. But it isn’t an issue that is unique to me. I know several other women who are childless. Some by choice; they don’t want kids. Some who desperately want kids and can’t or haven’t been able to as of yet. Frankly, having it flung at me, whether it’s said innocently or in anger, is one of the most hurtful things someone can say to me. And it reminded me of all the times someone has pointed out my childlessness.
You Don’t Understand. You Aren’t a Mother.
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard someone say “but you don’t have kids” as some sort of brush off. It’s an utterance often meant to give the person who said it the last word. It’s definitive. The person saying it desperately wants to be right; this is the point I can’t dispute. However, these are fighting words that can potentially break down relationships. Is it worth it?
We all have different stories
You see, we all have different stories. Not all of us can have or even want to have children. Some of us desperately want to be a mother and can’t have children. Some of us have had repeated miscarriages or tried loads of infertility treatments. We may have devastating chronic illnesses that make pregnancy unsafe. There are so many reasons another woman may be childless. And regardless of our reasons, telling us that we don’t understand something or that we do not know what love is because we don’t have kids is not okay.
Telling a woman she can’t understand something because she isn’t a mother is not okay.
Women are not less than if we are not mothers.
Women are not incapable of loving less because we are childless. It may be different, but not less.
While motherhood for most people is no doubt wonderful, some might say enviable, and a truly a loving state of being, it does not mean that those who are not mothers are morally inferior. And the inverse is also true.
Women who are not mothers are not inferior.
We are capable of empathy
Childless women are capable of empathy. We do not lack the faculties of reason. We do not lack the ability to see things from someone else’s viewpoint. Well, most of us anyway.
So why do you say it? Pointing out that one is childless or using “you don’t have kids” is incredibly cruel thing to say, despite being factual. You may not even realize that it’s hurtful when you say it. You may think that you’re stating the obvious, and that it’s no big deal.
Why is it so hurtful?
Let’s break down why it’s hurtful and what you can say instead.
It negates the other’s opinion
First of all, it’s a statement that negates the other person’s opinion. If you have a disagreement and use this statement to give yourself the moral high ground, you’re really accomplishing the opposite. It doesn’t. In fact, it’s a low blow. You’re exerting your mother privilege to belittle someone else’s thoughts, opinions or feelings. By seeking empathy from someone else, you may be instead demonstrating a lack of empathy in yourself when you say such things.
Instead, try identifying the problem from a different view-point. Recognize that the other person feels differently, and honor that. You might say something like “I hear where you are coming from. My experience with my child leads me to feel differently.” You may not need to say anything further after that.
You may not know what someone else has experienced
Secondly, you may or may not know what someone else has gone through or how she feels about it. When you use “you don’t have kids” as a point in your argument or discussion, you may not be aware that person spent her life’s savings on IVF and failed. She may have had a miscarriage. Your friend may have fostered a child she loved and had to return to the system. She may have been trying to adopt without success or wasn’t able to afford the process.
Maybe you do know what she’s dealt with and it slipped out anyway…
It’s like when kids on the playground poke on each other’s bruises. They know it’s probably going to hurt, and yet they push on the bruise anyway. In this situation, whatever high ground you think you have established, you have actually lost it because you have kicked someone verbally while they are down. Even if you didn’t mean to.
If you say this, you really should find a way to sincerely apologize. Whatever point you may have been trying to make most likely isn’t nearly as important as the devastating blow you just delivered. It’s not worth it to continue driving your point about whatever it may be at the cost of hurting someone else so much. Seek common ground instead.
Further reading on The Awesome Muse
If you enjoyed this post, you may also enjoy reading more about how we talk to ourselves. We have a series from The Awesome Muse writer, Kim Jones, discussing how our self talk and trying to be perfect undermines our lives. Accepting our flaws help us to be free. It is a two-part series.
Trisha Walker says
People can be so hurtful with their comments. Great article Jennifer
Angie Samborski says
Thank you ,so many people including myself who are childless and get this from mothers .I have stopped speaking to people for it.So rude and. classless .My husband and I love children .Do you think we have no empathy or logic because we are not parents ?
Kristen Wilson says
OMG… yes.. this is soooo not okay. I have many friends that don’t have children and they have been great role models even for my children… when I say Happy Mother’s Day, it includes those who are like a mother to someone, because we all are..
Apolline Adiju says
Telling another woman that is cruel. It doesn’t matter if you have kids or not, we are all human and have our different ways to reacting to situations not matter the circumstances.
Robin says
Can’t believe this is still said in today time. Many women delay having kids, and one never knows why someone does not have kids. Good article!
Candess M. Campbell says
So sorry to hear this Jennifer. Mothering is archetypal and does not have to do with giving birth at all. Its is great you have this plat form to inform and educate.
Alene Geed says
Thanks for posting this Jennifer. I did not have children by choice. I married later in life but always felt it was not my path to be a Mom. I am so appreciative of those who did help create our next generation but knew it was not how I would express myself in this lifetime
Carol Rundle says
I, too, couldn’t have children for medical reasons. I tried to adopt. That didn’t work out. I spent decades grieving the loss of children I would never have. One time, someone asked me if I missed having children. I asked him if he missed living in Alaska. He said he never lived in Alaska so he didn’t know. I said, “Exactly.” He wasn’t being cruel, he was just clueless.
Geniece Brown says
Hi Jennifer,
I have two children that I naturally birthed and grateful for them, but just because I have children and another women doesn’t or cannot have children doesn’t make them any less of a woman or mother. There are women who have birthed children and given them up or neglected them for whatever reason. I believe being a mother is a way of thinking and how you behave. As women, I also believe we were innately created with a natural sense of nurturing which is needed to be a mother or to take the role of mother for any child who may look to us as a mother figure.
Catherine Tatum says
Wonderful powerful testimony. Thanks for sharing.
Tandy Elisala says
Saying to a woman that she wouldn’t understand because she’s not a mother is completely unacceptable. I feel so bad for women who can’t have children of their own yet there are LOTS of opportunities for women to be mothers. Just as there are many opportunities for men to be fathers to children. I hope this article helps someone gain a different perspective.
Michael Fite says
I want to say that this post hit home for me because my wife had to deal with that for almost 10 years before we had our first child. She has PCOS and it was near impossible for her to have a child. Although we would do our best to help other people who had kids, there was always that statement of we do not understand because we did not have kids ourselves. Your testimony is powerful because I do not think people know how it feels when they say that. I know that they mean well, but it reminds us that sometimes we have to think about what we say to others when their intent is to be of help.
Katarina Andersson says
A typical trait of women with children, to think that they are more than others. When my friends children were small I noticed my friends always tended to criticize all their single friends saying they are unhappy and miserable people for not having reached the level of marriage and motherhood, but soon when they would find a guy, they would be able to be happy too. At the time I was very annoyed and bored by hanging out with these friends, and just took a step away from them, but then I realized it was their own expression of jealousy and discontent. So in the end, it is just to ignore and move on…there are always going to be women with Medieval mindsets ;-)…when their children then grow or they separate from their husbands, they realize often how narrow minded they were… That has been my experience 😉
Randolph says
This website is really cool. I have bookmarked it. Do you allow guest posts on your page?
I can write high quality posts for you. Please let me know.
Genevieve Talbert says
I needed to find this article. I found it today. This happened to me today. And it hurt. I am that woman, the one who “doesn’t have kids”. It doesn’t mean I am a lesser woman.
Jennifer Quisenberry says
I’m so sorry it happened to you, Genevieve. It really does hurt. I hope I was able to help a bit.